Showing posts with label From Shia Books. Show all posts
Showing posts with label From Shia Books. Show all posts


The martyrdom of al-Husayn and the general atmosphere of mourning amongst the Shia during the month of Muharram bears testimony to its importance in the Shi’i calendar. To the Shia, ‘Ashura’ is probably the most important day of the year.

In this partial account of what actually happened at Karbala’, which conveniently draws attention away from the other guilty party in the ‘Ashura’ tragedy, lies another tragedy in itself. For while al-Husayn’s martyrdom has been oft commemorated, and his physical opponents and killers identified, cursed and eliminated, no one has spared a moment’s anger for those who deserted him at the crucial hour. It is these men in the shadows, who squarely deserve to be called the real villains of Karbala’, upon whom this article seeks to cast light - the Shia of Kufah.





Shia authorities, historians and writers confirm that it was the Shia of Kufah, after deserting al-Husayn, and acting treacherously even though the pledge of allegiance they had given was still around their necks, came to kill him and take his family captive. The following quotes are all from Shia authorities.

The advice of Muhammad bin al-Hanafiyyah, the brother of al-Husayn, who said to al-Husayn:
O my brother, you already know the treachery of the people of Kufah towards your father and brother. And I fear that your affair will be the same as that of he who has already passed." ]al-Malhoof of Ibn Tawoos (p. 39), Aashooraa of al-Ihsaa'ee (p. 115), al-Majaalis al-Faakhirah of Abd al-Husayn (p. 75), Muntahaa al-Aamaal of Abbaas al-Qummee (1/454).]

The saying of al-Husayn about the Shia of Kufah:
O Allaah, judge between us and between a people who requested us to aid us, but who then killed us. [Muntahaa al-Aamaal of Abbaas al-Qummee (1/535)]

The Shia writer, Husayn al-Kawraani writes:
The people of Kufah did not suffice with splitting from al-Imaam al-Husayn, but the result of their changing their colours led to a third position which is that they began to prepare to depart to Karbalah in order to wage war against al-Imaam al-Husayn (alayhis salaam). And in Karbala they would hasten (racing each other) to take up their positions, those which pleased Shaytan and which anger al-Rahmaan (Allaah). For example we find that Amr bin al-Hajjaaj who only yesterday was prominent in Kufah as if he was the guardian of the sanctuary of Ahl al-Bayt, and a defender of them, and the one who led an army to save Haani bin Urwah, went on to stomach (gulped) all of his apparent position(s) in order to accuse al-Imam al-Husayn of exiting from the religion, let us reflect upon the following text: "And Amr bin al-Hajjaaj used to say to his companions, 'Fight the one who exited from the religion and separated from the jamaa'ah (meaning al-Husayn)...'." Fee Rihaab al-Karbalaa (pp. 60-61)

And al-Kawraani also writes:
And we find another stance indicating the hypocrisy of the people of Kufah, Abd Allaah bin Hawzah al-Tameemi came in front of al-Imaam al-Husayn (alayhis salaam) and shouted, "Is Husayn amongst you?" Yet he was from the people of Kufah and only yesterday was he from the Shia (party) of Alee (alayhis salaam) and it is possible that he was from amongst those who wrote to al-Imaam (al-Husayn) or from the group of Shabath and others who wrote (to al-Husayn from Kufah)... then he (comes and says) "O Husayn, receive glad tidings of the Fire..."! [Fee Rihab al-Karbalaa (p. 61)]

And another Shia author, Murtadaa Mutahhiree writes, answering the question he asks himself: How did the people of Kufah embark on fighting al-Husayn (alayhis salaam) despite their love of him and their sentimental attachment to him?:
And the answer is the awe and fear which had taken root upon the people of Kufah in general since the time of Ziyad and Mu'awiyah, and which increased and grew to alarming proportions upon the arrival of Ubayd Allaah [bin Ziyaad] who upon arrival immediately killed Maytham al-Timaar, Rasheed, Muslim and Haani ... [al-Malhamah al-Husayniyyah (3/47-48)]

The Shia, Kaadhim al-Ihsaa'ee al-Najafee says:
The army that set out to wage war against al-Imaam al-Husayin (alayhis salaam) were 300,000 (in number) all of them were from the people of Kufah. There was not amongst them any Shaamee, Hijaazee, Hindee, Baakistaanee, Sudaanee, Misree, or Afreeqee. Rather, all of them were from the people of Kufah and they had gathered together from many diverse tribes. [Aashooraa (p. 89)]

The Shia historian, Husayn bin Ahmad al-Baraaqee al-Najafee said:
Al-Qazweenee said: And from that which for which scorn was shown to the people of Kufah was that they reviled al-Hasan bin Ali (alayhimaa as-salaam), and killed al-Husayn (alayhis salaam) after they themselves had invited him (to be their leader). [Taareekh al-Kufah (p. 113)]

And the Shia reference point, Aayat Allaah al-Udhmaa Muhsin al-Ameen said:
Then 20,000 from the people of Iraq who had given the pledge of allegiance to al-Husayn acted treacherously to him, revolted against him whilst their pledge of allegiance was around their necks, and killed him.

And Jawaad Muhdithee said:
And Imaam al-Hasan was faced by them with treachery, and Muslim bin Aqeel was killed unjustly whilst in their midst and al-Husayn was killed whilst languishing in Karbala, close to Kufah and at the hands of the army of Kufah.

Numerous Shia authorities, from their Shaykhs, quote from Ali bin al-Husayn bin Ali bin Abi Taalib (known as Zayn al-Aabideen) that he addressed the Shia who deserted his father and killed him, reviling them, saying:
O people, we implore you by Allaah, do you know that you wrote to my father and you deceived him and you gave him the pledge, the covenant, and you killed him and deserted him? So may you perish for what you have sent forth for yourselves, and for your evil opinionn. With which eye will you look towards the Messenger of Allaah (sallallaahu alayhi wa aalihi wa sallam) when he says to you, "You killed my family, and you violated my sanctity, so you are not from me." [Al-Tabarsee in al-Ihtijaaj (2/32), Ibn Taawoos in al-Malhoof (p. 92), al-Ameen in al-Lawaa'ij al-Ashjaann (p. 158), Abbaas al-Qummee in Muntahaa al-Aamaal (1/572), Husayn Kawrani in Fee Rihaab al-Karbalaa (p. 183), Abd al-Razzaaq al-Muqrim in Maqtal Husayn ((p. 317), Murtadaa Iyaad in Maqtal Husayn (p. 87) and Ridhaa al-Qawzeenee in Tadhlim al-Zahraa (p. 262), Abbaas al-Qummee in Nafs al-Mahmoom (p. 360)]

And when Ali bin al-Husayn Zayn al-Aabideen (rahimahullaah) saw the people of Kufah wailing and crying, he rebuked them, saying:
You wail and cry for us, so who are the ones who killed us? [Maqtal Husayn of Murtadaa Iyaad (p. 83), Tadhlim al-Zahraa of al-Qazweenee (p. 257) and al-Malhoof of Ibn Taawoos (p. 86), Nafs al-Mahmoom of Abbaas al-Qummee (p. 357)]

And in another narration that he was passing by them and he was ill and he said in a weak voice:
Are you wailing and crying for us? Who are the ones who killed us? [Abbaas al-Qummee in Muntahaa al-Aamaal (1/570)]

And in another narration that he said:
These people cry over us but who killed us other than them? [Al-Ihtijaaj of al-Tabarsee (2/29)]

And Shia sources quoted Umm Kulthum bint Ali (radiallaahu anhumaa) as saying:
O people of Kufah, disgrace upon you. What is with you that you deserted Husayn and killed him and you plundered his wealth and inherited it, and you took his women as captives, and you caused him distress. May you perish and may you be annihilated ... what burden have you carried upon your backs and which blood have you shed ... you killed the best of men after the Prophet (sallallaahu alayhi wa aalihi) and mercy has been snatched from your hearts. [Nafs al-Mahmoom (p. 262), Maqtal Husayn of al-Muqrim (p. 316), Lawaa'ij al-Ashjaan (p. 157) and others.]

And the Shia, Asad Haydar quotes from Zaynab bint Ali bin Abi Taalib (radiallaahu anhumaa), which is also mentioned by al-Tabarsee in al-Ihtijaaj (2/29-30):
أما بعد يا أهل الكوفة، يا أهل الختل والغدر والخذل .. إنما مثلكم كمثل التي نقضت غزلها من بعد قوة أنكاثاً، هل فيكم إلا الصلف والعجب والشنف والكذب .. أتبكون أخي؟! أجل والله فابكوا كثيراً واضحكوا قليلاً فقد ابليتم بعارها .. وانى ترخصون قتل سليل خاتم النبوة 
To proceed, O people of Kufah, O people of deception, treachery and desertion ... your example is like she who spins (yarn) only to break it after its strength. Is there anything in you but bragging, amazement, rank hatred and lying ... do you cry for my brother?! Yes, by Allaah, cry much and laugh little, for you have been put to trial through its infamy ... and how do you consider cheap the killing of the descendant of the Seal of the Prophethood. [Ma'al-Husayn Fee Nahdatihi (p. 295)]

Muhsin al-Ameen al-Husaynee al-Aaamilee says in his book "Fee Rihaab A'immah Ahl al-Bayt" (1/9):
Zahar bin Qays, he participated in the [battles] of al-Jamal and Siffeen with Ali (alayhis salaam), and Shabath bin Rub'ee and Shammar bin Dhil-Jawshan al-Diyaabee also witnessed [the battle] of Siffeen with him. Then they waged war against al-Husayn (alayhis salaam) on the day of Karbalaa, so it was an evil end (soo' al-khaatimah) for them and we seek refuge in Allaah from the evil end.

And in the book al-Irshaad of the well-known and famous Shia scholar, al-Shaykh al-Mufeed (2/95-96 onwards) mentions those who set out to fight and kill Husayn:
وأصبح عمر بن سعد في ذلك اليوم وهو يوم الجمعة وقيل يوم السبت، فعبأ أصحابه وخرج فيمن معه من الناس نحو الحسين عليه السلام وكان على ميمنته عمرو بن الحجاج، وعلى ميسرته شمر بن ذي الجوشن، وعلى الخيل عروة بن قيس، وعلى الرجالة شبث بن ربعي، وأعطى الراية دريدا مولاه 
And Umar bin Sa'd arose that morning, and it was the day of Jumu'ah (Friday), and it is said it was Saturday and he mobilized his companions, and then set out with those people who were with him towards the direction of al-Husayn (alayhis salaam), and on his right was Amr bin al-Haaj, and on his left was Shammar bin Dhil-Jawshan, and in charge of the horsemen was Urwah bin Qays and in charge of the infantry was Shabath bin Rub'ee and he gave the flag to Durayd, his mawlaa.

Then over the next twenty or so pages he gives an account of the fighting, culminating in the killing of al-Husayn (radiallaahu anhu) by Shammar bin Dhil-Jawshan.

Comments

The sayings of Ahl al-Bayt to the Shia of Kufah, "You wail and cry over us, yet you are the ones who killed us" exposes the fraud, scam and sham that underlies the deen of the Shia which is based upon a ridiculous type of hatred and it is a sign of the lack of intelligence and of simple-mindedness (or otherwise a sign of the deranged maniac-like nature) of those who knowing full well that their own Shia ancestry killed al-Husayn (radiallaahu anhu), harbour the greatest of resentment and hatred towards those who do not share in their simpleton type understanding of history and do not share in their bloodthirsty type of rage, based upon a fake display of anger for the blood of al-Husayn, for they (their Shia ancestors) are the very people who killed al-Husayn after deserting him and being treacherous to him. Then this fake wailing, lamenting and crying became one of the bidahs of the Shia to this day of ours. Refer to the book "Man Qatala al-Husayn" by Abd Allaah bin Abd al-Azeez (Cairo) for further information.


Source: "Shia Authorities and Historians on Who Murdered al-Husayn" at www.shia.bs

All taken from their books...

1. They said Allah will not speak to your sunni 'brothers', not purify them, and they will receive the painful azab... 

عن أبي عبد الله (عليه السلام) قال: سمعته يقول: ثلاثة لا يكلمهم الله يوم القيامة ولا يزكيهم ولهم عذاب أليم: من ادعى إمامة من الله ليست له، ومن جحد إماما من الله، ومن زعم أن لهما في الإسلام نصيبا.


...From Abu Abdullah he said, I heard him said : (( Three groups of people that Allah will not speak to them during the day of judgement : 1) One who claimed the Imamate from Allah while he's not,
2) One who rejected the Imam from Allah, 
and 3) The one who claimed that these two groups ( 1 & 2) have some portion of Islam.)) " [ Usul Kafi: Bab One who claimed to be the Imam while he is not, and one who rejects the imams or some of them, and one who attribute to someone as an imam while he is not ]. 




  • Nu'many in his book al-Ghaibah: " ...Muhamad bin Muslim said : I asked Abu Ja'far : " What do you say about someone who rejects an Imam from Allah, what is his status? He answered : " Whoever rejects an imam from Allah and disassociates himself from his(imam's) deen, then he is KAFIR, MURTAD from Islam, because the Imam from Allah and his deen is the deen of Allah, whoever disassociates himself from the the deen of Allah, then his blood is HALAL until he returns to repent to Allah from what he said."

     :Al-Majilisi said

      : " اعلم أن إطلاق لفظ الشرك والكفر على من لم يعتقد إمامة أمير - المؤمنين و الأئمة من ولده ع وفضل عليهم غيرهم يدل على أنهم كفار مخلدون في النار وقد مر الكلام فيه في أبواب المعاد وسيأتي في أبواب الإيمان والكفر إنشاء الله تعالى
    "
    " Know that the mention of the words Syirik and Kufur on those who didn't believe in the Imamate of Amirul Mukminin and the Imams from his offsprings, and their tafdheel(favouring) of others before them is proof that they are KUFFAR, FOREVER DWELLERS OF HELL, and this has been mentioned in the book of Ma'ad ( day after), and will be mentioned in the books of Iman and Kufur 
    God willing. "

    بحار الأنوار للمجلسي (1111 هـ) الجزء 23 صفحة 390 باب 21 : تأويل المؤمنين والإيمان


3. INFALLIBE ABU ABDULAH SAID: DON'T GIVE SADAQAH TO AHLI SUNNAH(NASIBITES) AND SYIAH ZAIDIYAH, DON'T FEED THEM WATER IF YOU CAN, FOR THEY ARE KUFFAR


روى الكشي أيضا عن حمدويه، عن ابن يزيد، عن محمد بن عمر، عن ابن عذافر، عن عمر بن يزيد قال: سألت أبا عبد الله عليه السلام عن الصدقة على الناصب وعلى الزيدية قال: لا تصدق عليهم بشئ، ولا تسقهم من الماء إن استطعت، وقال لي: الزيدية هم النصاب.
Majlisi narrating from Rijal Kashyi in Biharul Anwar :{37/34)

4. INFALLIBLE ABUL HASAN: NASIBI AND ZAIDI ARE THE SAME, BOTH DISBELIEVED IN QURAN, PROPHETS AND MESSENGERS
 الحسين بن محمد الأشعري عن علي بن محمد بن سعيد عن محمد بن 
سالم بن أبي سلمة عن محمد بن سعيد بن غزوان قال : حدثني عبد الله بن المغيرة قال : قلت لأبي الحسن: إن لي جارين أحدهما ناصب والآخر زيدي ولا بد من معاشرتهما فمن أعاشر فقال : هما سيان من كذب بآية من كتاب الله فقد نبذ الاسلام وراء ظهره وهو المكذب بجميع القرآن والأنبياء والمرسلين قال : ثم قال : إن هذا نصب لك وهذا الزيدي نصب لنا .

...from Abdullah bin Mughirah : " I asked Abul Hasasn : " I have two girl slaves, one a Nasibi, another a Zaidi, and I must mix with them, which one can I mix with?" 

He answered : " Both are the same! One who disbelieved a verse from the Book of Allah has thrown Islam behind him, he is a disbeliever to all of the Quran, all Prophets and Messengers." 

Then he said : " This is your enemy, and this Zaidi is our enemy."

[ Usul al-Kafi by Kulaini (329H) : 8/235 ]

5. INFALLIBLE ABU ABDULLAH SAID : ALLAH DO NOT ACCEPT HAJ FROM NON SYIAH..HAJ IS ONLY FOR SYIAH

- سهل بن زياد، عن محمد بن سنان، عن حماد بن أبي طلحة، عن معاذ بن كثير قال: نظرت إلى الموقف والناس فيه كثير فدنوت إلى أبي عبد الله (عليه السلام) فقلت له: إن أهل الموقف لكثير؟ قال:
فصرف ببصره فأداره فيهم ثم قال: ادن مني يا أبا عبد الله، غثاء يأتي به الموج من كل مكان لا والله ما الحج إلا لكم، لا والله ما يتقبل الله إلا منكم.

...from Muaz bin Katsir : " I looked at Arafah and people are many there..I neared to Abu Abdullah and told him : " Verily the people doing wuquf are so many?

He turned his look towards them, and then he said : " Come near me O Abu Abdillah, these are just DIRT from waves all over the place. No, I swear with Allah, hajj is only for you people. No, by Allah, Allah will not accept ( hajj ) except from you people."

[Usul Kafi by Kulaini ( 329H ) : 8/327 no 318.]

6. INFALLIBLE SAJJAD : " ONE WHO PRAYED THE LIFETIME OF NOAH A.S 950 YEARS BETWEEN RUKUN HAJAR ASWAD AND MAQAM, MEETS ALLAH WITHOUT OUR WILAYAH, IT WILL NOT BENEFIT HIM AT ALL."

[308] 12 ـ محمد بن علي بن الحسين، بإسناده، عن أبي حمزة الثمالي، قال: قال لنا علي بن الحسين ( عليه السلام ): أي البقاع أفضل؟ فقلنا: الله ورسوله وابن رسوله أعلم، فقال لنا: أفضل البقاع ما بين الركن والمقام، ولو أن رجلا عمر ما عمر نوح في قومه، ألف سنة إلا خمسين عاما، يصوم النهار، ويقوم الليل في ذلك المكان، ثم لقى الله بغير ولايتنا لم ينفعه ذلك شيئا.

...from Abu Hamzah: " Ali ibnul Husain ( Sajjad) said : " What is the best place on earth?" We said : " Allah, His Messenger and His Messenger's son know best "

He said to us : " The best place is between Rukun and Maqam, if a man's life is lengthened to the lifetime of Noah, 950 years, fasting in the day, praying at night at that place, then he dies meeting Allah without acknowledging our Wilayah, all (this worship) will not benefit him at all."

[Wasail Syiah : Bab : The Nullifucation of Ibadat Without the Wilayah of Imams And the Believe In Their Imamate : page 121 no 308. ]

7. INFALLIBLE ABU JA'FAR : ِALLAH WILL PUNISH ALL CITIZENS OF ISLAM ACCEPTING THE WILAYAH OF ANYL UNJUST IMAM NOT FROM ALLAH EVEN IF THERE WERE SOME CITIZENS HAVING VIRTUOUS DEEDS

- وعنه، عن هشام بن سالم، عن حبيب السجستاني، عن أبي جعفر (عليه السلام) قال: قال الله تبارك وتعالى: لاعذبن كل رعية في الاسلام دانت بولاية كل إمام جائر ليس من الله، وإن كانت الرعية في أعمالها برة تقية، ولاعفون عن كل رعية في الاسلام دانت بولاية كل إمام عادل من الله وإن كانت الرعيه في أنفسها ظالمة مسيئة.

...From Abu Ja'far : Allah said : " I will surely punish all citizens of Islam who accepted the wilayah of any unjust imam that is not from Allah, even if there are some citizens having virtuous deeds. 

And I will surely forgive all citizens of Islam who accepted the wilayah of the just imam from Allah, even if all of these citizens themselves were unjust and having evil deeds. "

[ Usul al-Kafi by Kulaini (329H) : Bab: One who accepted the Imam not from Allah: pg375 ]

8. THE INFALLIBLE ABU ABDULLAH: A SUNNI WHO EMBRACED SYIAH MUST REDO HIS HAJ AND REPAY HIS ZAKAT

[318] 2 ـ وعن عدة من أصحابنا عن سهل بن زياد وأحمد بن محمد جميعا، عن أحمد بن محمد بن أبي نصر، عن علي بن أبي حمزة، عن أبي بصير، عن أبي عبدالله ( عليه السلام ) قال ـ في حديث ـ: وكذلك الناصب إذا عرف، فعليه الحج وان كان قد حج.

...from Abu Baseer, from Abu Abdullah in a hadith : " So is the Nasibi who had known ( accepted the true Imam ), he must make hajj even if he had done so ( while being a non Syiah ) "

[317] 1 ـ محمد بن الحسن بإسناده عن موسى بن القاسم، عن صفوان وابن أبي عمير، عن عمر بن أذينة، عن بريد بن معاوية العجلي، عن أبي عبدالله ( عليه السلام ) ـ في حديث ـ قال: كل عمل عمله وهو في حال نصبه (1) وضلالته، ثم من الله عليه وعرفه الولاية، فإنه يؤجر عليه، إلا الزكاة فإنه يعيدها، لأنه وضعها في غير مواضعها، لأنها لأهل الولاية، وأما الصلاة، والحج، والصيام، فليس عليه قضاء.

...from Buraid bin Muawiyah al-Ijli, from Abu Abdullah in a hadith : " Every action while he was a Nasibi ( non Syiah Imamiyah) and in his deviance, then Allah guide him to the Wilayah , he will be rewarded for it EXCEPT ZAKAT, for he must repay it, because he payed it not to its proper place, because zakat is for Ahlil Wilayah ( Syiah only ), as for solat, hajj, fast, there is no need to qada' " 

I say, Nasib refers to all non Imamiyah, where Sunnis are the top of the list, and it includes all other brands of Syiah, not even Zaidis!

321] 5 ـ وفي ( الذكرى ) نقلا من كتاب علي بن إسماعيل الميثمي، عن محمد بن حكيم قال: كنت عند أبي عبدالله ( عليه السلام ) إذ دخل عليه كوفيان كانا زيديين، فقالا (1): إنا كنا نقول بقول، وإن الله من علينا بولايتك، فهل يقبل شيء من أعمالنا؟ فقال: أما الصلاة، والصوم، والحج، والصدقة، فإن الله يتبعكما ذلك ويلحق بكما، وأما الزكاة فلا، لأنكما أبعدتما حق امرىء مسلم، وأعطيتماه غيره.

...from Muhammad bin Hakeem: " I was with Abu Abdullah when two former Zaidis from Kufah entered and said : " We used to believe in a belief ( Zaidiyah ), then Allah granted us with your Wilayah, will any of our past actions be accepted?"

He answered : " As for solat, fast, haj and giving alms, Allah will count them and reward you, but as for ZAKAH, NO! Because you took away the right of a Muslim, and instead gave it to someone else. " "

Ref: Wasail Syiah :Bab : Not Compulsory to Redo Ibadat After Given Guidance ( to the Imamate ) Except Zakat If he Pays to the Unrightful one, and Haj If he leaves a rukun.

Note : There's a contradiction in the narrations above regarding The point is clear, these Syiahs look at others as Kuffar, doomed to Hell, that is what lies between those Syiah smiles.

9. THE INFALLIBLE ABU ABDULLAH : ONE WHO REJECTS THE WILAYAH IS LIKE THE WORSHIPPER OF AN IDOL

Majlisi narrates in his Biharul Anwar : 
0 - بصائر الدرجات : أحمد بن الحسين عن أحمد بن إبراهيم عن الحسن بن البراء عن علي ابن حسان عن عبد الرحمان يعني ابن كثير قال : حججت مع أبي عبد الله ع فلما صرنا في بعض الطريق صعد على جبل فأشرف فنظر إلى الناس فقال : ما أكثر الضجيج وأقل الحجيج ؟ فقال له داود الرقي : يا بن رسول الله هل يستجيب الله دعاء هذا الجمع الذي أرى ؟ قال : ويحك يا با سليمان إن الله لا يغفر أن يشرك به الجاحد لولاية علي كعابد وثن . قال : قلت : جعلت فداك هل تعرفون محبكم ومبغضكم ؟ قال : ويحك يا أبا سليمان إنه ليس من عبد يولد إلا كتب بين عينيه : مؤمن أو كافر وإن الرجل ليدخل إلينا بولايتنا وبالبراءة من أعدائنا فنرى مكتوبا بين عينيه : مؤمن أو كافر قال الله عز وجل : ( إن في ذلك لايات للمتوسمين ) نعرف عدونا من ولينا

...from Abdur Rahman ibnu Kathir : " I performed haj with Abu Abdullah, while we were at some road he climbed a hill, taking the view and looked at the people and said : " What a lot of noise and so few Hujjaj?

Daud ar-Raqiy said to him : " O son of Rasulullah! Will Allah answer prayers of these people that I see?

He answered : " Destruction on you O Abu Sulaiman! Verily Allah will not forgive those who is a musyrik, ONE WHO REJECTS THE WILAYAH OF ALI IS LIKE THE WORSHIPPER OF AN IDOL!"

I said : " May I be your ransom! Do you ( Imams ) know your lovers and your haters? "

He answered : " Destruction on you O Abu Sulaiman! There is not a single baby born except that it was written between his eyes ' Mukmin' or ' Kafir '. And verily, a man enters to our place with our Wilayah and the rejection of our enemies while we SEE wirtten between his eyes : ' Mukmin ' or 'Kafir'...""

[ Biharul Anwar : 27/181. Bab : Actions Are not Accepted Without Wilayah ]

10. THE INFALLIBLE SAJJAD : ABU BAKAR AND UMAR ARE KAFIRS, KAFIR ONE WHO LOVES THEM!

. روى الشيخ الجليل أبي الصلاح الحلبي (رضي الله عنه) بسنده: عن أبي علي الخراساني عن مولى لعلي بن الحسين عليهما السّلام قال: كنت مع علي بن الحسين عليه السّلام في بعض خلواته؛ فقلت إنّ لي عليك حقّا، ألا تخبرني عن الرجلين، عن أبي بكر وعمر؟
فقال: كافران، كافر من أحبّهما.
(تقريب المعارف للحلبي ص244).

The ' beloved' Majlisi reported in his al-Bihar : " Syaikh Abu Solah ah-Halabi narrated with his sanad : from Ali al-Khurasani, from Maula to Ali bin al-Husain ( Sajjad ):

" I was in private with Ali bin Husain and I said : " I have a right on you that you must tell me about the two men, Abu Bakar and Umar?"

He answered : " Both are KAFIRS, and kafir anyone who loves them!" "

[ Biharul Anwar : 29/137 Bab : The Kufur of the Mukhalifin and Nasibis ]

11. THE INFALLIBLE SAJJAD : ABU BAKAR AND UMAR ARE KAFIRS, KAFIR ONE WHO LOVES THEM!

. روى الشيخ الجليل أبي الصلاح الحلبي (رضي الله عنه) بسنده: عن أبي علي الخراساني عن مولى لعلي بن الحسين عليهما السّلام قال: كنت مع علي بن الحسين عليه السّلام في بعض خلواته؛ فقلت إنّ لي عليك حقّا، ألا تخبرني عن الرجلين، عن أبي بكر وعمر؟
فقال: كافران، كافر من أحبّهما.
(تقريب المعارف للحلبي ص244).

The ' beloved' Majlisi reported in his al-Bihar : " Syaikh Abu Solah ah-Halabi narrated with his sanad : from Ali al-Khurasani, from Maula of Ali bin al-Husain ( Sajjad ):

" I was in private with Ali bin Husain and I said : " I have a right on you that you must tell me about the two men, Abu Bakar and Umar?"

He answered : " Both are KAFIRS, and kafir is anyone who loves them!" "

[ Biharul Anwar : 29/137 Bab : The Kufur of the Mukhalifin and Nasibis ]

12. THE INFALLIBLE ABU JA'FAR : THE TWO SYAIKHS ( Abu Bakar and Umar ) DIED WITHOUT TAUBAH FOR WHAT THEY DID TO AMIRUL MUKMININ ( ALI ), THE CURSE OF ALLAH, THE ANGELS AND ALL MANKIND ON BOTH OF THEM

. حديث صحيح رواه الكليني (قدس الله نفسه) بسنده عن سدير الصيرفي عن أبي جعفر الباقر (عليه السلام) قال: ”إن الشيخين فارقا الدنيا ولم يتوبا ولم يتذكّرا ما صنعا بأمير المؤمنين عليه السلام، فعليهما لعنة الله والملائكة والناس أجمعين“. (الكافي ج8 ص246).

[ Kulaini in his al-Kafi : 8/ 246 ]




Sayyed Muhammad Al Sadr Says: And the Tribe of Unayzah was tracking all those who enter and exit Karbala, and threatens to steal and rob them So the road to karbala was very dangerous and the people feared it, If it weren't for the fact that Al Imam al Mahdi PBUH lead them to the Ziyarah on the road to karbala and the fact that he threatened the Bani Unayzah with complete destruction and death if they tried to attack them Then the people wouldn't have been able to visit the Master of youths of Paradise al imam al hussein PBUH and this great Islamic ritual would have been stopped. So Cheers for the Kindness that Al Mahdi PBUH bestows upon his Ummah.

Source: Tareekh al Ghaybah al Kubrah, Sayyed Muhammad al Sadr, 2/117.

Mashallah I am astonished at the bravery of this Imam, everyday we hear more and more heroics from this great Super Hidden Human Dinosaur thingy.

Here's a similar story narrated by Sayyed Mahdi al Qazwini in more detail from "Arwa'a al Qisas fi man Ra'ah al Imam al Mahdi" or "the most amazing stories of those who saw Imam al Mahdi"


حدثني مشافهة سيد الفقهاء وسند العلماء العالم الرباني السيد مهدي القزويني ساكن الحلة، قال (أيده الله):

خرجت اليوم الرابع عشر من شبعان من الحلة أريد زيارة الحسين (صلوات الله عليه) ليلة النصف منه، فلما وصلت إلى شط الهندية وعبرت إلى الجانب الغربي منه، وجدت الزوار الذاهبين من الحلة وأطرافها والواردين من النجف ونواحيه محاصرين جمعياً في بيوت عشيرة بني طرف من عشائر الهندية، ولا طريق لهم إلى كربلاء لأن عشيرة بني عنيزة قد نزلت على الطريق وقطعته عن المارة ولا يدع أفرادها أحداً يخرج من كربلاء ولا أحداً يلج إليها إلا انتهبوه.

قال: فنزلت على رجل من العرب وصليت صلاة الظهر والعصر وجلست انتظر ما يكون من أمر الزوار، وقد تغيمت السماء وأمطرت مطراً يسيراً.

فبينما نحن جلوس إذ خرج الزوار بأسرهم من البيوتات متوجهين نحو طريق كربلاء، فقلت لبعض من معي: اخرج واسأل ما الخبر، فخرج ورجع إلي وقال لي: إن عشيرة بني طرف قد خرجوا بالأسحلة النارية وتعهدوا بإيصال الزوار إلى كربلاء، وآل الأمر إلى القتال مع بني عنيزة.

فلما سمعت ذلك قلت لمن معي: هذا الكلام لا أصل له، لأن بني طرف لا قدره لهم على مقابلة بني عنيزة، وأظن هذه مكيدة منهم لإخراج الزوار عن بيوتهم، لأنهم استثقلوا بقاءهم عندهم في ضيافتهم.

فبينما نحن كذلك إذ رجع الزوار إلى البيوت، فتبين الحال كما قيل، ولم يدخل الزوار إلى البيوت بل جلسوا في ظلالها والسماء متغيمة، فأخذني لهم رقة شديدة وأصابني انكسار عظيم، فتوجهت إلى الله بالدعاء والتوسل بالنبي وآله وطلبت إغاثة الزوار مما هم فيه.

فبينما على هذه الحال، إذ أقبل فارس على فرس كريم لم أر مثله، وبيده رمح طويل وهو مشمر عن ذراعيه، فأقبل يخب به جواده حتى وقف على البيت الذي أنا فيه، وكان بيتاً من الشعر مرفوع الجوانب، فسلم فرددنا عليه السلام، فقال: يا مولانا ـ يسميني باسمي ـ، بعثني من يسلم عليك وهم كنج محمد آغا وصفر آغا وكانا من قواد العساكر العثمانية، ويقولان: فليأت الزوار، فإنا قد طردنا عنيزة عن طريقهم ونحن ننتظره مع عسكرنا في عرقوب السليمانية على الجادة، فقلت له: وأنت معنا إلى عرقوب السليمانية؟ قال: نعم، فأخرجت الساعة فإذا قد بقي من النهار ساعتان ونصف تقريباً، فقلت: إلينا بخليلنا، فقدمت إلينا، فتعلق بي ذلك البدوي الذي نحن عنده وقال: يا مولاي، لا تخاطر بنفسك وبالزوار، وأقم الليلة حتى يتضح الأمر، فقلت له: لا بد من الركوب لإدراك الزيارة المخصوصة.

فلما رآنا الزوار قد ركبنا تبعوا أثرنا بين راجل وراكب، فسرنا والفارس المذكور بين أيدينا كأنه الأسد الخادر، ونحن خلفه حتى وصلنا إلى عرقوب السليمانية، فصعد عليه وتبعناه في الصعود ثم نزل وارتقينا إلى أعلى العرقوب، فنظرنا فلم نر له عيناً ولا أثراً، فكأنما صعد في السماء أو نزل في الأرض، ولم نر قائداً ولا عسكراً، فقلت لمن معي: أبقي شك في أنه صاحب الأمر؟ فقالوا: لا والله، كنت وهو بين أيدينا أطيل النظر إليه كأني رأيته من قبل، لكنني لا أذكر أين رأيته، فلما فارقنا تذكرت أنه الشخص الذي زارني بالحلة وأخبرني بواقعة السليمانية.

وأما عشيرة عنيزة فلم نر أثراً لهم في منازلهم، ولم نر أحداً نسأله عنهم سوى أننا رأينا غبرة شديدة مرتفعة في كبد البر، فوردنا كربلاء تخب بنا خيولنا، فوصلنا إلى باب البلد وإذا بعسكر على السور، فنادوا: من أين جئتم وكيف وصلتم؟ ثم نظروا إلى سواد الزوار فقالوا: سبحان الله، والبرية امتلأت بالزوار فأين صارت عشيرة عنيزة؟ فقلت لهم: اجلسوا في البلد وخذوا أرزاقكم ولمكة رب يرعاها، وهذا القول مضمون كلام عبد المطلب حين صار إلى ملك الحبشة في طلب إبله التي استولى عليها الأحباش، فقال له الملك: ولم لا تطلب مني رد البيت إليكم؟ فقال: أنا رب الإبل وللبيت رب يحميه.

قال: فدخلنا البلد، فإذا بكنج محمد آغا جالساً على تخت قريب من الباب، فسلمت عليه فقام في وجهي، فقلت له: يكفيك فخراً أنك ذكرت باللسان، فقال: ما الخبر؟ فأخبرته بالقصة، فقال لي: يا مولاي من أين أعلم أنك قادم للزيارة حتى أرسل لك رسولاً؟ وأنا عسكري منذ خمسة عشر يوماً محاصرون في البلد، لا نستطيع الخروج خوفاً من عنيزة؟

ثم قال لي: فأين صارت عنيزة؟ قلت: لا علم لي سوى أني رأيت غبرة شديدة في كبد البر كأنها غبرة الظعائن، ثم أخرجت الساعة وإذا قد بقي من النهار ساعة ونصف، فكان مسيرنا كله في ساعة وبين منازل بني طرف وكربلاء فراسخ، ثم بتنا تلك الليلة بكربلاء، فلما أصبحنا سألنا عن خبر عنيزة، فأخبرنا بعض الفلاحين ممن في بساتين كربلاء قال: بينما عنيزة جلوس في أنديتهم وبيوتهم إذا بفارس قد طلع عليهم على فرس مطهم وبيده رمح طويل، فصرخ فيهم بأعلى صوته: يا معشر عنيزة قد جاءكم الموت الزؤام، عساكر الدولة العثمانية متوجهة إليكم بخليها ورجالها وها هم على أثري مقبلون، فارحلوا وما أظنكم تنجون منهم، فألقى الله فيهم الخوف والذل حتى أن الرجل منهم يترك بعض متاع بيته استعجالاً للرحيل، فلم تمض ساعة حتى ارتحلوا بأجمعهم وتوجهوا نحو البر، فقلت له: صف لي الفارس، فوصفه لي فإذا هو صاحبنا بعينه.

المصدر: أروع القصص فيمن رأى الامام المهدي (عليه السلام)



"Imam al Sadiq said ... So Allah most high says: (Indeed, Allah is not timid to present an example - that of a mosquito or what is smaller than it.) Al Sadiq said: My father told me that he heard from al Nudr bin Suwaid from al Qasam bin Suleiman from Mu'ula bin Khanees from Imam Abu abdullah PBUH who said: This example was presented from Allah to Ameer Ali PBUH, so the mosquito was Ameer Ali PBUH and "what is smaller than it" is The Prophet PBUH, and the proof for this is his saying (And those who have believed know that it is the truth from their Lord. ) meaning Ameer Ali ... "

Tafseer al Qummi 1/48, Beirut Lebanon.

Mashallah what a great Tafseer for this Verse, It Seems the Shiites want to "Force" their religion into the Quran but are having a hard time Since no where is the Imamat of the twelve Or Ali RAA are mentioned... So they settle for the mosquito ... and BTW I think the "What is smaller than it" means the wing of a mosquito if I recall correctly...

Honestly they read too much into The Quran these "batini" clowns , I'll give you a better example of this:

في قول الله تعالى: ((اللَّهُ نُورُ السَّمَوَاتِ وَالأَرْضِ)) [النور:35]: يا علي [النور] اسمي، [والمشكاة] أنت يا علي، [مصباح، مصباح] الحسن والحسين، [الزجاجة] علي بن الحسين، [كأنها كوكب دري] محمد بن علي، [يوقد من شجرة] جعفر بن محمد، [مباركة] موسى بن جعفر، [زيتونة] علي بن موسى، [لا شرقية] محمد بن علي، [ولا غربية] علي بن محمد، [يكاد زيتها] الحسن بن علي، [يضيء] قائم المهدي

the following verse (( Allah is the Light of the heavens and the earth. The example of His light is like a niche within which is a lamp, the lamp is within glass, the glass as if it were a pearly [white] star lit from [the oil of] a blessed olive tree, neither of the east nor of the west, whose oil would almost glow even if untouched by fire. Light upon light. Allah guides to His light whom He wills. And Allah presents examples for the people, and Allah is Knowing of all things.)) [24:35]


The Shiite attribute to one of their Imams ( Ali RAA ) that he said: The names of Us Ahlul Bayt are mentioned in the Quran, his followers asked how? he said the saying of Allah (Allah is the Light of the heavens and the earth.), Ya Ali [the Light] is my name, [and the niche] Is you O Ali, [Lamp, Lamp] Al Hassan and Al hussein, [The Glass] Ali bin Hussein, [pearly star] Muhammad Bin Ali, [Lit from a Tree] Ja'afar bin muhammad, [blessed] Musa bin Ja'afar, [Olive] Ali bin Musa, [neither of the east] Muhammad bin Ali, [nor of the west] Ali bin Muhammad, [whose oil would] Al hassan bin Ali, [Glow] Al Qa'em al Mahdi.

Source: Ithbat al Hudat 1/668.


That explains everything...





Classical Shia grand scholar Muhammad bin Ibrahim bin Ja`far al-Nu`mani (died 360 A.H) says in his book “al-Ghaybah” pages 27-28:
أما بعد : فإنا رأينا طوائف من العصابة المنسوبة إلى التشيع ، المنتمية إلى نبيها محمد وآله صلى الله عليهم – ممن يقول بالإمامة التي جعلها الله برحمته دين الحق ، ولسان الصدق ، وزينا لمن دخل فيها ، ونجاة وجمالا لمن كان من أهلها ، وفاز بذمتها ، وتمسك بعقدتها ، ووفى لها بشروطها ، من المواظبة على الصلوات ، وإيتاء الزكوات ، والمسابقة إلى الخيرات ، واجتناب الفواحش والمنكرات ، والتنزه عن سائر المحظورات ، ومراقبة الله تقدس ذكره في الملأ والخلوات ، وتشغل القلوب وإتعاب الأنفس والأبدان في حيازة القربات – ، قد تفرقت كلمها ، وتشعبت مذاهبها ، واستهانت بفرائض الله عز وجل ، وخفت إلى محارم الله تعالى ، فطال بعضها علوا ، وانخفض بعضها تقصيرا ، وشكوا جميعا إلا القليل في إمام زمانهم ، وولي أمرهم ، وحجة ربهم التي اختارها بعلمه
[We saw the groups that are attributed to Tashayyu` and the Prophet and his family upon them be peace, from those who believed in the Imamah that Allah with his mercy has made truthful, and has made it a merit for the one who embraces it, and salvation and beauty for those belonging to it [...] They have divided in sayings and sects, and they begun to take the orders and prohibitions of Allah lightly, some have risen to extremes while others have dropped into lenience, and they ALL have doubted the Imam of their time and the one in authority of their affairs and the Hujjah of their Lord whom he picked with his wisdom except a small few]
So he’s confirming what we read in Firaq al-Shia by al-Nawbakhti and other books that the Shia were extremely divided and misguided and almost all of them never knew who their Imams were.



  • Shia scholar Muhammad Nabi al-Tusirkani “محمد نبي التوسيركاني” wrote a small note in his book, he wrote “تنبيه” or in English “Attention” in order to grab the attention of the Shia readers, so let’s see what he wants the readers to know:

    ...
    ” تنبيه: اعلم أن أشرف الأمكنة والأوقات والحالات وأنسبها للعن عليهم – عليهم اللعنة – إذا كنت في المبال، فقل عند كل واحد من التخلية والاستبراء والتطهير مرارا بفراغ من البال: اللهم العن عمر، ثم أبا بكر وعمر، ثم عثمان وعمر، ثم معاوية وعمر، ثم يزيد وعمر، ثم ابن زياد وعمر، ثم ابن سعد وعمر، ثم شمر وعمر، ثم عسكرهم وعمر. اللهم العن عائشة وحفصة وهند وأم الحكم والعن من رضي بأفعالهم إلى يوم القيامة“.

    [Attention: Know that the most honorable of places and times and conditions and the best occasion to send curses on them - may they be cursed- is in the area of urination (i.e bathroom), so when you are free from urine say during each Takhliya and Istibra' and Tathir continuously: "O Allah curse `Umar then Abu Bakr, and `Umar and `Uthman, and `Umar then Mu`awiyah, and `Umar then Yazid, and `Umar then ibn Ziyad, and `Umar then ibn Sa`d, and `Umar then Shamir, and `Umar then their armies, and `Umar. O Allah curse `Aisha and Hafsa and Hind and Umm al-Hakam, and curse the ones who are pleased with their actions until the day of judgement."]

    source: لئالئ الأخبار – La’ali’ al-Akhbar 4/92, by al-Muhaqqiq al-Tusirkani.

    What a lovely religion this is.

حرمة الغيبة مشروطة بالايمان: قوله: ثم ان ظاهر الاخبار اختصاص حرمة الغيبة بالمؤمن. أقول: المراد من المؤمن هنا من آمن بالله وبرسوله وبالمعاد وبالائمة الاثنى عشر (عليهم السلام)، اولهم علي بن أبي طالب (عليه السلام) وآخرهم القائم الحجة المنتظر عجل الله فرجه وجعلنا من أعوانه وأنصاره، ومن أنكر واحدا منهم جازت غيبته لوجوه: 1 – انه ثبت في الروايات (1) والادعية والزيارات جواز لعن المخالفين، ووجوب البراءة منهم، واكثار السب عليهم واتهامهم، والوقيعة فيهم اي غيبتهم، لانهم من اهل البدع والريب (2). بل لا شبهة في كفرهم، لان انكار الولاية والائمة (عليهم السلام) حتى الواحد منهم والاعتقاد بخلافة غيرهم، وبالعقائد الخرافية كالجبر ونحوه يوجب الكفر والزندقة، وتدل عليه الاخبار المتواترة (3) الظاهرة في كفر منكر الولاية وكفر المعتقد بالعقائد المذكورة وما يشبهها من الضلالات

Reference: Mishbahul Fuqahah 2/11, Dar Al-Huda, Beirut Libanon
Online Reference From Shia website:
http://www.yasoob.com/books/htm1/m001/05/no0507.html

Translation:
[I say: What is meant by "believer" here is the one who believes in Allah and his messenger and the last day and the twelve Imams (as), starting with `Ali bin abi Talib (as) and ending with al-Qa'em al-Hujjah, the awaited one may Allah hasten his appearance and make us among his supporters, and he who denies one of them then it is allowed to backbite him for several reasons:
1- It has been proven in the narrations and Ziyarat and supplications that it is permissible to curse the ones who oppose us, and that it is obligatory to disown them, and increase their insults, and accuse them, and slander them, meaning to backbite them because they are from the people of innovation and doubt. There is no doubt about their Kufr, because denying al-Wilayah and the Imams (as) even if just one, and to believe in the Khilafah of others, and to believe in myths such as al-Jabr and other beliefs necessities Kufr and Zandaqah, as mentioned in the Mutawatir narrations that clearly demonstrate the Kufr of the rejector of al-Wilayah, and the Kufr of the one who believes in the mentioned beliefs and similar other misguided beliefs.
2- Those who oppose us commit Fisq publicly, because their deeds are annulled by default as stated by the countless narrations. They even adopted what is greater than Fisq as you now know, and we will mention later that it is permissible to backbite the one who commits Fisq publicly.
3- What we benefit from the verse and the narrations is that it is forbidden to backbite against the believing brother, and it is obvious that there is no brotherhood or sanctity between us and those who oppose us.
4- It is famous and spread since the past among the laypeople of the Shia and their scholars that they used to backbite against the ones who oppose us, rather they used to insult them and curse them at all times and in all lands, in fact it is mentioned in "al-Jawahir" that this is from the necessities.]

After we’re done, now let me show you Taqqiyah:

Imam al-Khu’i's charity foundation called for a conference entitled “الوحدة الإسلامية والمذاهب الفقهية” “Islamic unity and schools of jurisprudence”:

كلمة سماحته في ندوة الاجتماع الدولي لوضع استراتيجية مشتركة للتقريب بين المذاهب الإسلامية المنعقد في فندق إيبلا الشام بدعوة من مؤسسة الإمام الخوئي الخيرية خلال الفترة 10 – 12 /4/1999م

This was held in Damascus 10/12/1999.



The Shia say they believe that the Prophet SAWS does not forget, they attack the rest of the Muslims who do not believe this and claim that we are insulting the Prophet SAWS if we say he makes “Sahu”, little do the Shia know that their scholars hide many things from them and here in the introduction to “Man la Yahduruhu al-Faqih” the Shia scholar al-’Allamah al-Sheikh Muhammad Jawad al-Faqih writes:

مقدمة كتاب من لايحضره الفقيه – ج 1 – ص 70
9/ جواز السهو على النبي (ص) وسماه اسهاء من الله تعالى تبع في رايه ذلك شيخه محمد بن الحسن بن الوليد وتبعه على رأيه ذلك الشيخ الطبرسي في مجمع البيان كما نقل عنه التنكانبي في قصص العلماء والسيد الجزائري في الانوار النعمانية وفخر الدين الطريحي في مجمع البيان مادة (بدا) والمحقق الفيض الكاشاني في الوافي على مايظهر من كلامه ونقل عن الشيخ البهائي رحمه الله انه قال : ( الحمد لله الذي قطع عمره ولم يوفقه لكتابة مثل ذلك ) ونقل عن الشيخ أحمد الاحسائي انه قال : ( الصدوق في هذه المسألة كذوب ) ولايخلو قولهما من سوء ادب نربأ بامثالهما عن ذلك ونسأل الله العصمة والتوفيق . . . أ.هـ

(9) The permissibility of Sahu (forgetfulness) for the Prophet SAWS: From those who saw this are Muhammad bin al-Hassan bin al-Walid and from those who followed him in his opinion are Sheikh al-Tabrasi in Majma’a al-Bayan as reported from him by Sheikh al-Tinkanbi in Qasas al-’Ulemaa, also al-Sayyed al-Jazaeri in al-Anwar al-Nu’umaniyyah, also Fakhr al-Deen al-Tarihi in Majma’a al-Bayan and al-Muhaqqiq al-Faydh al-Kashani in al-Wafi from what is apparent.
It is reported by al-Sheikh al-Bahaee (rah) that he said (About al-Saduq): “Praise be to Allah who cut his life and did not allow him to write what he intended.” and Sheikh Ahmad al-Ahissaee said (About al-Saduq): “In this matter al-Saduq is a liar.” both of them have displayed poor Adab by saying this and we did not expect this from people such as them…
source: introduction of Man la Yahduruhu al-Faqih vol.1 pg.70

So based on this, some of the biggest classical Shia scholars on the face of the planet used to believe that the infallible prophet SAWS does forget, from those they named:

1- Ibn Babawei al-Qummi al-Saduq.
2- Muhammad ibn al-Hassan ibn al-Walid.
3- Ameen al-Deen abu ‘Ali al-Fadl bin al-Hussein bin al-Fadl al-Tabrasi.
4- Ni’imatullah al-Jazaeree.
5- Fakhr al-Deen al-Tarihi.
6- al-Faydh al-Kashani.

We also see how some of the shia scholars made Du’ah and thanked Allah for ending the life of al-Saduq as they never agreed with him in matters of ‘Aqeedah.






حقائق الإيمان – الشهيد الثاني – ص 150 – 151
فهل يعتبر في تحقق الإيمان أم يكفي اعتقاد إمامتهم ووجوب طاعتهم في الجملة ؟ فيه الوجهان السابقان في النبوة . ويمكن ترجيح الأول ، بأن الذي دل على ثبوت إمامتهم دل على جميع ما ذكرناه خصوصا العصمة ، لثبوتها بالعقل والنقل . وليس بعيدا الاكتفاء بالأخير ، علي ما يظهر من حال رواتهم ومعاصريهم من شيعتهم في أحاديثهم عليهم السلام ، فإن كثيرا منهم ما كانوا يعتقدون عصمتهم لخفائها عليهم ، بل كانوا يعتقدون أنهم علماء أبرار ، يعرف ذلك من تتبع سيرهم وأحاديثهم وفي كتاب أبي عمرو الكشي ( 1 ) رحمه الله جملة مطلعة على ذلك ، مع أن المعلوم من سيرتهم عليهم السلام مع هؤلاء أنهم كانوا حاكمين بإيمانهم بل عدالتهم . وهل يكفي في كل شخص اعتقاد إمامة من مضى منهم عليهم السلام إلى إمام زمانه وإن لم يعتقد إمامة الأئمة الباقين الذين وجدوا وانتهت الإمامة إليهم بعد انقراضه الظاهر ذلك ، وفي كثير من كتب الأحاديث والرجال ما يشعر بذلك ، فليطلب منهما . والدليل إنما يدل على وجوب اعتقاد إمامة ( 2 ) الاثنا عشر بالنظر إلى من تأخر زمانه عن تمام عددهم عليهم السلام ، فليتأمل ، كيف ؟ ! وقد كانوا في كل زمان مخفيين مشردين منزوين ملتزمين للتقية في أكثر أو قاتهم ، لا يستطيعون إخبار خواصهم بإمامتهم فضلا عن غيرهم ، يشهد بذلك كتب الرجال والأحاديث أيضا ، وحينئذ فلا بد من الاكتفاء بما ذكرناه ،والالزام خروج أكثر شيعتهم عن الإيمان ، وهو باطل . أ.هـ
The renowned Shia scholar of Hadith al-Shaheed al-Thani says in his book“Haqaeq al-Iman” pages 150-152:
“What is apparent from the condition of their Shia who lived in their time and narrated from them the Ahadeeth may peace be upon them, that MANY OF THEM did not believe in their infallibility because it was hidden from them but they used to believe that the Imams were pious obedient scholars, anyone who follows their stories and narrations knows this” 
after a few lines he says:
“How!? they were hidden and isolated at all times and they practised taqiyyah most of the time, so they couldn’t tell even their closest followers about their Imamah let alone the others, the books of Rijal and the Ahadeeth are proof of this”
قال المامقاني في كتابه ( تنقيح المقال ) 6 / 340 :
لكن قول ابن الغضائري يوهم قبول روايته تارة ، ولا يبعد أنّهم كانوا يقبلون رواياته الخالية من الغلوّ ويتركون ما كان فيه غلوّ. وحيث إنّ الغلوّ عند القدماء ينسب إلى الرجل بأدنى شيء ، بل أكثر ما نعتقده الآن في أهل البيت عليهم السلام كانوا يومئذ يسمّونه غلوّاً . أ.هــ
Shia scholar al-Mamaqani says in his book “Tanqeeh al-Maqal” volume 6 page 340:
“Our predecessors used to ascribe Ghulu to the smallest things, in fact the majority of the things we believe in today regarding Ahlul-Bayt peace be upon them used to be called Ghulu by our predecessors.” 

Our Objectives


Shia.sg was initiated by a group of concerned Muslims who were active in a Facebook group called "Kampung Melayu" which was mainly a platform for Singapore Muslims.


Unfortunately, the Facebook group admitted members from the local Shi'ite community, including their leader, Rosli Hassan.

>> Read more...

Local News about Deviant Shi'a Cult in M'sia


Self-Flagellation Ritual of Muharram


Most Read Articles